Showing posts with label deflation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label deflation. Show all posts

Thursday, October 01, 2009

Price Levels

Everyone’s attention seems to be focused on whether we’ll see deflation or inflation in the US economy (and in the global economy) as we move forward.

On the deflation side, we have the moribund housing market, falling or stagnant consumer spending, along with falling incomes and rising unemployment, and on the inflation side we have truly massive money creation led by the Fed, followed by the Treasury, and finally by the Federal government in the form of federal stimulus packages, all on borrowed money.

Which of these two forces will prove to be more powerful?

I live in San Francisco, one of the more expensive urban centers in the country. In my neighborhood, I see flyers posted that say “One Hour Massage, $40”. It caught my attention because I think that price is half to a third the price you would have paid two years ago. Basic economics: if goods and services won’t sell at a given price, then the price will fall.

The bond market may provide us with a clue, as bond investors are highly concerned about inflation. The yield on the bellwether 10-yr US Treasury bond has been dropping rapidly. Since mid August, the yield has fallen from 3.8% to close below 3.2%. This may mean that bond investors are taking a stand on deflation, but it may also mean that investors see the rally in the stock market ending soon, and they’re getting back into Treasuries for a safe haven. The surge in gold prices to close above $1,000 for six days seems to lend support to the safe haven thesis, but it also could support the inflation thesis.

Oil and copper are also important signals to the strength of the global economy. Both seem indecisive after strong gains this year. The same can be said for the CRB commodities index, which is up 25% from its low this year, recorded back in March.

Given all this indecision, we may see a bifurcation, with certain commodities and services rising while others fall. We await, with bated breath, the next round of economic developments. The latest labor market data indicate that the US economy shed 263,000 jobs last month, for a total of about 7.2 million jobs lost so far during this recession. That is a truly stunning number, made all the more serious when one considers that the economy must create 150,000 jobs or so each month in order to simply keep pace with population growth.

Tuesday, August 11, 2009

Economic Medicine and Poison, part 1

The most helpful thing we could possibly do for the economic corpus is to create a sound currency that is linked to a stable banking system.

Right now we have neither, and so we have risks to the economy that are simply unknown. A risk that you don't know is always worse than one you can understand. Will your bank be around tomorrow? This is no longer an idle question.

Creating a stable currency would not be hard. It's a simple matter of pricing, and there is nothing that markets do better than pricing, when they are allowed to function without interference. Take an item of real value, one that cannot be produced by the printing press. Let's say, I don't know, how about the gold standard of money?

Gold has been used as money for 5000 years or more. Let's say we go back to using gold as money. You want to sell something. OK, how many grams of gold would you accept to part with it? You want to buy something. How many grams would you give up to obtain it?

The thing is, we're used to using dollars as our standard. We think, "how many dollars is that worth?", not "how many grams?" Like visitors in another country, we'll be running the numbers through our heads, converting to dollars. At least for a while. Pretty soon we'll get the hang of it.

If we get rid of the risky fractional reserve system (perhaps following this great plan by Kotlikoff and Leamer), then we have the absolute best basis for economic prosperity. Systematic inflation becomes impossible. And deflation has no power to wreak economic havoc. Deflation becomes your friend, because deflation is simply falling prices. We only associate deflation with the end of the world because deflation has typically occurred only at the end of a credit bubble, as the harbinger of deep recession, bringing with it financial panic and high unemployment.

The problem is how the stable currency would interact with the dollar. The dollar decays like a radioactive isotope. A stable currency operating in parallel with the dollar would instantly reveal what a poor currency the dollar really is. Fewer assets would be held in dollars, and fewer transactions would be made in dollars. Both would cause a reduction in the demand for dollars, and a depreciation in the value of the dollar. Perhaps that would be viewed as an "attack" on the dollar. It's not an attack to remove lipstick from a pig. (My apologies to Mrs. Palin.)

The dollar is worth about what the paper it's printed on is worth, and to put it next to a commodity with real value simply reveals that truth.


Wednesday, June 17, 2009

Deflation

The Bureau of Labor Statistics released the Consumer Price Index yesterday, which shows a very small monthly increase since April (0.1%), but the story that's grabbing the headlines is the 12-month drop in prices, or deflation, to the tune of negative 1.3%.

It's a bait and switch story. What number do we emphasize? The scary number, about the deflationary monster? Or perhaps the core inflation number, which excludes food and energy, and shows a 12-month increase of 1.8%? Only two categories in the CPI fell: transportation and energy. Both are tied to the fall in oil and gas prices. Every other category increased.

What does this tell us?

Expect inflation, not deflation to prevail in the coming months.

Tuesday, June 16, 2009

Ah, Krugman!

To sum up: A few months ago the U.S. economy was in danger of falling into depression. Aggressive monetary policy and deficit spending have, for the time being, averted that danger. And suddenly critics are demanding that we call the whole thing off, and revert to business as usual.
The above is a quote from the marvelous Paul Krugman. I love him; and yet, he's so wrong right now.

Let's be clear: aggressive monetary and fiscal policy have not averted any danger to the economy. The danger is not inflation, nor is it deflation. The danger is economic distortions. That is, massive investment in unproductive economic activity (retail, advertising, finance, etc.). This kind of economic activity does not produce anything, and hence it is the major threat to the economy.

Why are there economic distortions? Why should it be the case that the market, which often gets things right, ought to be disastrously wrong? What causes the distortions is the massive inflation of the money supply. That may lead to inflation or it may even lead to stable prices, even deflation for a time. It all depends on how the extra dollars are used. If they are saved, no inflation in consumer prices. If dollars are spent elsewhere in the world, no inflation (at least in the US). If those extra dollars are spent in the US, expect to see some inflation.

Rising or falling prices is not the danger. The danger is that there is a prolonged period of confusion: what are my assets worth? Is my business viable? Should I start this business? What is the market saying?

If the answers to these questions are unusually obscure for a long period of time, the result will be stagnation, low growth, and unemployment. This is the danger. And it's in full bloom now. More aggressive monetary and fiscal policy will worsen the situation, not make it better.