Showing posts with label unemployment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label unemployment. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 07, 2009

Greed vs Fear

Treasuries and gold are fear investments. Investors have bid up the price of 10-year Treasury bonds, driving down the yield to 3.178%. Fear. Gold has just hit a new high, $1038. More fear. Stocks are a greed investment, and stocks are looking tired, moving sideways after a 7 month rally. As the rally has continued, volume has seen a mild but steady decline.

If Wall Street is torn between greed and fear, what about Main Street? Unemployment continues to rise, hitting 9.8% as of last month. The economy seems to be continuing to shed jobs, albeit at a slower pace. Incomes are falling, as is the average workweek. More are working part-time when they’d like to have full time jobs. The housing market continues to decline, offering a benefit for some Americans: falling rents. Thousands of condos that cannot be sold, and thousands of homes that were bought by speculators who don’t want to sell at current prices but need cash to pay the mortgage hit the rental market, have pushed rents steadily downward. In addition, people are consolidating, doing with less.

People are even borrowing less. Total consumer credit has declined by 3.6% during this recession. Comparable declines haven’t been seen since 1991. Even with those declines, the consumer remains heavily mired in debt, so it seems reasonable to expect it will take consumers some time to lower their debt levels, as seems to be their preference. Many consumers are saying now that they wouldn’t return to their ‘spend now, pay later’ ways.

Corporations are facing the shock of billions of dollars of worthless assets clogging their balance sheets, or, even worse, these toxic assets are not on the balance sheet, because they are not being valued honestly. New accounting rules have allowed corporations more flexibility in their amortization of gains and losses, i.e., less transparency for investors, meaning more risk. Corporations have been hollowed out by two decades of mergers, acquisitions, restructurings, layoffs, and re-brandings. The CEO and upper management—facing little opposition from the Board of Directors, shareholders, workers, or other stakeholders—have looted the corporation. New models of leadership will be needed for corporations to move forward. I expect the wild executive compensation of the boom years will swiftly fade away.

Meanwhile the various levels of government struggle with massive revenue shortfalls and budget deficits. Most states are cutting spending and raising taxes. The former is good during a recession, the latter, disastrous. Many are following California’s example, turning toward debt to put off their budget problems. In the face of all this, the Federal government considers a health plan that will fine people who don’t have health insurance, and we debate over whether to call this a new tax or not.

In the battle between greed and fear, there is no contest. Indeed, I’ll believe in the recovery when I see some genuine signs that greed has returned.


Thursday, October 01, 2009

Price Levels

Everyone’s attention seems to be focused on whether we’ll see deflation or inflation in the US economy (and in the global economy) as we move forward.

On the deflation side, we have the moribund housing market, falling or stagnant consumer spending, along with falling incomes and rising unemployment, and on the inflation side we have truly massive money creation led by the Fed, followed by the Treasury, and finally by the Federal government in the form of federal stimulus packages, all on borrowed money.

Which of these two forces will prove to be more powerful?

I live in San Francisco, one of the more expensive urban centers in the country. In my neighborhood, I see flyers posted that say “One Hour Massage, $40”. It caught my attention because I think that price is half to a third the price you would have paid two years ago. Basic economics: if goods and services won’t sell at a given price, then the price will fall.

The bond market may provide us with a clue, as bond investors are highly concerned about inflation. The yield on the bellwether 10-yr US Treasury bond has been dropping rapidly. Since mid August, the yield has fallen from 3.8% to close below 3.2%. This may mean that bond investors are taking a stand on deflation, but it may also mean that investors see the rally in the stock market ending soon, and they’re getting back into Treasuries for a safe haven. The surge in gold prices to close above $1,000 for six days seems to lend support to the safe haven thesis, but it also could support the inflation thesis.

Oil and copper are also important signals to the strength of the global economy. Both seem indecisive after strong gains this year. The same can be said for the CRB commodities index, which is up 25% from its low this year, recorded back in March.

Given all this indecision, we may see a bifurcation, with certain commodities and services rising while others fall. We await, with bated breath, the next round of economic developments. The latest labor market data indicate that the US economy shed 263,000 jobs last month, for a total of about 7.2 million jobs lost so far during this recession. That is a truly stunning number, made all the more serious when one considers that the economy must create 150,000 jobs or so each month in order to simply keep pace with population growth.

Thursday, August 27, 2009

Is Inflation Coming Soon?

Most economists will tell you that there’s a tradeoff between inflation and unemployment (called the Phillips Curve), making it unlikely that a high unemployment economy generates unemployment. Well, expect to see the unlikely happen soon.

Here’s a chart of monthly inflation, as measured by the Consumer Price Index, since 2007:

The Federal Reserve is waging war against deflation, funnelling trillions of new dollars into the financial system in an attempt to defeat deflation.

The Fed will win; in fact, they’re already winning. Inflation has simply been channeled into the stock market. Oil has doubled in price. Gold has recovered from its low of the fall of 2008, when it dipped below $700, and is currently pushing $950. These are early signs of inflation.

An interesting feature of the CPI is that it’s not designed to measure changes in the cost of living. It’s designed to provide a measure of how much money it takes to maintain a constant level of satisfaction. That means the Bureau of Labor Statistics must do a very difficult thing: instead of merely measuring prices, they must measure our satisfaction. They do this by imputing value to technological changes, and by using sophisticated averaging techniques which attempt to measure how consumers make substitutions between products in response to price changes. The outcome of this fancy guessing-game is the most widely-quoted measure of inflation in the US, but CPI has little to do with what most think the CPI measures.

My guess is that we’re already seeing the kind of inflation that the Fed so fears: consumer price inflation. Prices ought to fall during a recession, and some have. But I think prices have not fallen as much as they should, given the extreme weakness in consumer demand. If the effect of money creation is the prevention of falling prices, that’s inflation, it just doesn’t look like it when we look at the CPI.

It’s clear that the Federal government would prefer inflation to deflation. With the ten-year deficit now officially projected to add $9 tril to the public debt (which would bring it above $20 tril), some inflation sure makes the interest easier to pay in depreciated dollars. I wonder if the American consumer will go along for this ride. Sure, inflation will probably kill your real wages, but it can also zap the value of your debts. Perhaps the average American won’t complain too much if inflation begins to roar. Much depends of what happens to the unemployment numbers as we move forward.

Sunday, August 23, 2009

Unemployment in the US

I’ve got a friend who has been unemployed for a year. She has a PhD in archaeology, and experience in both non-profit and for-profit organizations. A graduate degree tends to insulate one against unemployment; for many years the rate of unemployment for those with master’s degrees and higher was less than a third that of the rate for those with only a high school education. But this recession doesn’t spare the educated. Though the disparity between unemployment rates by educational attainment is still large, the recession has narrowed it.

California’s unemployment rate is pushing 12%. Michigan’s is 15%. (They were 7.3% and 8.3% a year ago). Unemployment rates have skyrocketed in the last year, and though this month’s national rate shows a slight improvement (9.5% to 9.4%), these numbers are still eye-popping.

An interesting feature of the numbers is that the labor force participation rates are also declining for all levels of education, as those who cannot find work become discouraged, or move to another activity, such as school, caregiving, or work in the informal economy. The Bureau of Labor Statistics’ U-6 unemployment rate attempts to capture the effect of people moving out of the labor force (or moving to part-time employment when they’d prefer full-time); the U-6 stands at 16.8%.

And these numbers have been getting steadily worse (or holding more or less steady) since the beginning of 2009. Even the BLS’s narrowest measure, called U-1, those unemployed 15 weeks or longer, is at a frightening 5.1%. That’s truly unreal. Over 5% of the labor force has been unemployed 31/2 months or more. In the face of this, the stock market has rallied 45%.

Why should unemployment be so high? It’s a grave sign that the economy has become sclerosed, and cannot quickly adjust the forces of supply and demand. This is the Great Contraction: you lose your job, you must cut expenses, more people per square foot of real estate, fewer hours spent on leisure. This is still the richest country in the world, with 90% of Americans still working. For the labor market to clear, wage rates would have to fall, and with them, so would the housing market, (both prices and rents would be relentlessly beaten down until they reached a proper proportion to household incomes). Many other prices would also fall. All those overpriced services will cost an awful lot less: think of haircuts, dog walkers, personal shoppers, personal assistants. These services and more will be driven down in price by falling demand and price competition on the supply side, as those remaining in these fields attempt to keep a portion of their sales.

What I’m saying has become anathema to the field of economics, yet it’s a simple truth: falling prices can be healthy for the economy. Yet we’re spending trillions to try to keep inflated prices high. If we simply stay out of the way, markets will clear and prices will find their natural level. Then a truly robust recovery can and will begin.

Friday, May 08, 2009

When Bad News Looks Good

As predicted, unemployment has indeed increased. The latest number from the Bureau of Labor Statistics is 8.9%, bringing the total number of people unemployed to 13.7 million.

The ranks of the marginally attached (those who want work and have looked in the recent past, but have given up and haven't been looking in the last 4 weeks) has been sharply increasing during the recession, and now stands at 2.1 million.

This is pretty bad news, but Wall Street seems to be giving it a positive spin; as the Wall Street Journal reports, job losses are "decelerating". Unfortunately, the slowing growth of job losses doesn't really count as good news, as much of the reason for the
lessening slack is new hiring by the government. Given the fiscal realities that the various levels of government are facing, it seems unlikely that government can pick up the slack for long.

The second piece of bad news is that the stress tests results are in: the Federal Reserve reckons that bank losses may be as high as $599 billion. It almost sounds like a sale, doesn't it? Act now, bank losses only $599, that's right, $599 billion!

The WSJ also has a poll, asking readers: Do the stress tests results paint an accurate picture of the financial services industry? When I checked the results, 88% had said no.

The table is from the Fed's report; it gives some of the assumptions that led to their results about the extent of bank losses.

The interesting thing about these numbers is how big they are. Under the baseline view, loss rates in subprime mortgages of 15-20%! That's the optimistic scenario! And 12-17% for credit cards - unreal. So given these huge loss rates, why didn't banks see it coming? Why did they make these loans? And why should they now rush in to lend more, with these kind of loss rates?



Friday, May 01, 2009

GDP Plunges, Unemployment Remains High

The Bureau of Economic Analysis reports that GDP contracted at an annual rate of 6.1% last quarter (the first quarter of 2009), following on a 6.3% rate of decline the quarter before.

Meanwhile, unemployment seems to be headed for further increases. The latest number from the Bureau of Labor Statistics is 8.5% for the headline unemployment statistic, which the BLS calls U-3. If workers who are "marginally attached" and underemployed (that is, they have given up searching for work, or they would like full time work but are working part time) are counted you get an unemployment rate of 15.6%. Incredible.

What ought to be done?

Given the circumstances unique to this recession, we ought to cut government spending, remove subsidies, cut taxes, refuse to prop up failed and insolvent corporations and banks, and simply allow the market to reach equilibrium.

Creating a system of sound honest money that is tied to a commodity (I favor gold) would stabilize the international monetary order, though it would cause some immediate pain in the short term. Abolishing fractional reserve banking would immediately solve the banking crisis, allowing banks to begin lending.


Monday, April 20, 2009

Nice Graphic on Unemployment by County


Check out Slate for a nice animated graphic on unemployment by county in the US.

The graph shows something that apparently Paul Krugman has forgotten: the real estate bubble actually did cause important economic distortions, which are now manifesting in real job losses.

Krugman argues that the real estate bubble isn't what's behind job losses now; I agree insofar as the real estate bubble is an intermediate rather than primary cause. The primary cause is the explosion of money created by the fractional reserve banking system, overseen by the Federal Reserve and the Federal government.




Sunday, March 22, 2009

A Prediction for the Dow

In the spring of 2006, my father and I predicted a financial crisis would hit the US. (We assumed that this crisis would be driven by dollar depreciation, which has not yet occurred). We continue to feel strongly that the dimensions of the coming crisis are still not grasped by most Americans. In January 2008, I predicted the Dow would fall to 7000. Given what has now occurred, our concerns were mild. Yes, an estimated $60 tril of paper wealth has been destroyed globally, but there is much more to come.
Over the next five or ten years, the US will sink into a deep recession. Unemployment will rise dramatically as the restructuring of the American economy proceeds. We see the Dow falling to 400. Yes, four hundred.
Given the endless parade of bad news and bearish forecasts for the economy, it may seem that the worst has already happened, and there is nowhere to go but up. Indeed, some analysts (for example here and here) have called a market bottom. The US consumer is not spending, unemployment is rising, the highest officeholders in the land call it the worst situation since the Great Depression... you might say, how many other shoes are there waiting to drop (or be thrown)?
What has not yet occurred is a serious threat to the dollar's status as the world's reserve currency. That threat will come, for the world cannot continue to finance American profligacy. When the eventual flight from the dollar occurs, it will cause much worse damage even than the unbelievable carnage in asset prices (click here for a chart of the Dow over the last year) we've already seen.