Bernanke on Financial Innovation

While there are legitimate financial innovations, e.g. the stock market, options, shorting stocks - many financial innovations are merely more sophisticated ways to gamble or rip someone off.

Fed chair Ben Bernanke offers an interesting argument about three financial innovations that he considers worthwhile and important. These are: credit cards, mortgages, and bank overdrafts.

There is a certain wolf-in-sheep's-clothing aspect to Bernanke's speech.

He says, in effect, gosh, some of these financial innovations haven't gone all that well. It's very challenging for regulators, because on the one hand, we don't want to stifle innovation, because that makes all our lives better. On the other hand, sometimes things get out of hand, we ought to consider how these innovations will react when they are "stressed", and recognize that regulation may be needed. Who could argue with these mild-mannered banalities?

Yet if we step back and ask the question, why should the Fed have a role to play in preventing people from getting fleeced? That doesn't seem like the Fed's role. People get ripped off all the time. It seems to me that a better defense against that than the Fed could ever be is this device called the internet. It sure seems like a great way to spread information to other consumers not to do things that end up being a huge rip-off.

And why would the Fed place restrictions on financial activity at all? We already have laws against fraud. What else is needed?

We have to recognize that the Fed has an impossible task: to prevent a house of cards from collapsing. The fractional reserve system is fundamentally insolvent. This is what creates a danger to financial stability in the first place. The reason that somebody not paying their mortgage may mean I lose my job is because banks are running the biggest fraud in history, an epic pyramid scheme that makes Bernie Madoff seem insignificant. And the job of the Fed is to oversee this fraud, to make sure that we keep it up, to continue to shovel an ever-increasing share of society's surplus value into the coffers of the banks. This is why it strikes me as rather disingenuous for Ben Bernanke to worry that complex mortgage products may not ultimately help the consumer. Talk about dodging the real issue.